Feb 13, 2019
The Case for Professors of Stupidity
Posted by Xavier Rosseel in category: neuroscience
Where do I sign up!? đ€Ș.
On this past International Holocaust Remembrance Day, I reread a bit of Bertrand Russell. In 1933, dismayed at the Nazification of Germany, the philosopher wrote âThe Triumph of Stupidity,â attributing the rise of Adolf Hitler to the organized fervor of stupid and brutal peopleâtwo qualities, he noted, that âusually go together.â He went on to make one of his most famous observations, that the âfundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.â
Russellâs quip prefigured the scientific discovery of a cognitive biasâthe DunningâKruger effectâthat has been so resonant that it has penetrated popular culture, inspiring, for example, an opera song (from Harvardâs annual Ig Nobel Award Ceremony): âSome peopleâs own incompetence somehow gives them a stupid sense that anything they do is first rate. They think itâs great.â No surprise, then, that psychologist Joyce Ehrlinger prefaced a 2008 paper she wrote with David Dunning and Justin Kruger, among others, with Russellâs commentâthe one he later made in his 1951 book, New Hopes for a Changing World: âOne of the painful things about our time is that those who feel certainty are stupid, and those with any imagination and understanding are filled with doubt and indecision.â âBy now,â Ehrlinger noted in that paper, âthis phenomenon has been demonstrated even for everyday tasks, about which individuals have likely received substantial feedback regarding their level of knowledge and skill.â Humans have shown a tendency, in other words, to be a bit thick about even the most mundane things, like how well they drive.